You've probably heard of various diets that claim to help you lose weight. You might be familiar with the likes of `Sugar Busters`, `Zone Diet`, `Nutrisystem`. The basis of almost all of these diets is the concept of the `Glycemic Index`. It was originally introduced to help diabetics control their blood sugar levels. So the theory is, "If you can control your blood sugar, you should also be able to lose weight, right?" Let's see if this story is true or not.
What is the Glycemic Index (GI)?
Simply put, it's a measure of how quickly a carbohydrate-containing food we eat raises our blood sugar. Some foods, like bread, biscuits, and potatoes, cause our blood sugar levels to rise quickly. But there are other foods that cause our blood sugar levels to rise more slowly and steadily.
Here is the basic idea of the `Glycemic Index` or GI system:
We give foods a score from 0 to 100 based on how quickly they raise our blood sugar levels.
- High GI foods: These are digested quickly and quickly increase blood sugar.
- Low GI foods: These take longer to digest, so they release sugar into the blood more slowly. They are high in fiber, which helps you feel fuller for longer. This also reduces the frequency of hunger.
Does this diet really help you lose weight?
This is the most important question. Adopting a low GI diet can go some way to preventing conditions like diabetes and heart disease.
However, there is still not enough scientific evidence to say that this method is more effective than a regular, balanced, low-fat diet for weight loss. Some studies have shown that people who ate a low-GI diet lost less body fat than those who ate a high-GI diet, even though they consumed the same amount of calories. But other studies have not found such a strong link. Therefore, scientific opinion on this issue is still divided.
The important thing is, this is not a magic bullet for weight loss. But it is a good tool for making smart decisions about the types of carbohydrates we eat.
What can and cannot we eat?
In this method, we should try to eat more foods in the low GI category and reduce the amount of foods in the high GI category as much as possible.
| GI category | Examples of food |
|---|---|
| High GI (70 or above) | White rice, bread, baked potatoes, crackers, sugary drinks, sweets |
| GI value is medium (56-69) | Grapes, spaghetti, ice cream, raisins, corn |
| Low GI (55 or less) | Oats, peanuts, chickpeas, green beans, red peas (Rajma), carrots, hummus (chickpea paste), low-fat milk, most fruits (except some fruits like watermelon) |
Is this difficult to follow?
There are some good things about this, and some things that are a little confusing.
Good things
You don't have to count calories or measure your food intake. And you don't have to cut out carbohydrates completely. All you have to do is pay attention to the GI value of the foods you eat and make smart choices.
Challenges and limitations
The GI system can be a bit confusing. Just because a food has a low GI doesn't mean it's healthy . Also, some foods with a high GI can have very good nutritional value.
For example, parsnips have a GI of 52. But vanilla cake has a GI of 42. Now do you understand the problem? Parsnips have a higher GI than cake. But what is better in terms of nutrition?
Another thing is, this method only talks about carbohydrates. It doesn't give any guidance on how much protein, fat, or calories you should consume per day. That's your responsibility.
Also, eating a high GI carbohydrate with protein and fat can change the rate at which blood sugar levels rise. So it's not as simple as you might think.
My opinion as a doctor
Here's how I see it. The `Glycemic Index Diet` is not really a diet designed for weight loss. It's a great tool for diabetics to manage their blood sugar levels. It's very helpful for someone with diabetes to consider this GI value when choosing carbohydrates.
Also, if you are at risk of developing diabetes (prediabetes) or have a condition called insulin resistance, this method may be helpful for you. Someone who has high blood pressure, heart disease, cholesterol, and overweight is likely to have this insulin resistance.
But remember, the GI value is only one part of the story.
For example, sweet potatoes have a relatively high GI, but they are a very nutritious food. Similarly, nuts like peanuts have a low GI. But if you eat too much of them, you can increase your calorie intake and gain weight.
So, use the GI as a guide to your carbohydrate choices. But at the same time, be mindful of your protein, fat, and total calorie intake. Your overall diet should be balanced.
If you're feeling confused about these things, there are other meal plans that have been designed with everything in mind. That may be more suitable for you. The best thing to do is to talk to your doctor and decide what diet is best for your health.
Take-Home Message
- The Glycemic Index (GI) is a measure of how quickly a food raises our blood sugar levels.
- This method was originally designed to help diabetics control their blood sugar levels.
- Scientific evidence is not conclusive on how effective this method is for weight loss.
- Just because a food has a low GI doesn't always mean it's healthy, and some foods with a high GI may have good nutrition.
- This is not a complete meal plan, but rather a tool to help you make smart choices about carbohydrate-containing foods.
- If you have diabetes or are at risk for diabetes, it is very important to discuss this method with your doctor.


💬 අදහස් (0)
තවමත් කිසිදු අදහසක් පළ කර නොමැත. ඔබේ අදහස පළමු වරට මෙහි එක් කරන්න.
ඔබේ අදහස එක් කරන්න